What’s due

14 songs you might reasonably expect tonight

Songs you are expecting: ones the band plays often enough to have a habit, which are now a little past it. Measured against each song’s own recent gaps rather than one number for the whole catalog — a staple is late at eight shows and a rarity is not late at eighty. The figure on the right is how far past: 2× means it has now been twice this song’s usual gap, which is printed under it.

How these lists are measured

Being late is not the same as being expected, and more late is not more expected. A song at six times its usual gap is not one anybody is waiting on — it is drifting out of rotation. So past 3.5× a song is slipping rather than due, past 100 shows it is on the shelf, and with no recent habit at all it is out of rotation. All four are below, though the fourth is a count and a door rather than a list: there are more songs in it than in the other three put together, so they have a page to themselves.

None of this knows what the band has planned. A themed night overrides every figure here — the 2021 Halloween runs built around numbers and animals, the elements nights of the first Sphere run, a run played entirely out of one decade — and the theme is usually not public before the show. On a night like that the list below is the wrong question.

The FAQ answers this at more length, including why a song gone for years is not on the list.

Due
14
Slipping
22
On the shelf
8
Out of rotation
284
Song Last playedHow late
  1. Evolve2026-07-12Noblesville, IN3.2×16 shows sinceusual gap 5
  2. Martian Monster2026-04-17Las Vegas, NV3.1×28 shows sinceusual gap 9
  3. Hey Stranger2026-07-10Noblesville, IN18 shows sinceusual gap 6
  4. Meat2025-09-21Hampton, VA2.9×38 shows sinceusual gap 13
  5. 5552026-07-11Noblesville, IN2.8×17 shows sinceusual gap 6
  6. The Well2026-04-25Las Vegas, NV2.7×24 shows sinceusual gap 9
  7. Piper2026-07-14Savannah, GA2.5×15 shows sinceusual gap 6
  8. Twenty Years Later2026-04-16Las Vegas, NV2.4×29 shows sinceusual gap 12
  9. Steam2026-07-14Savannah, GA2.3×15 shows sinceusual gap 6.5
  10. Drift While You’re Sleeping2026-07-15Savannah, GA14 shows sinceusual gap 7
  11. Pillow Jets2026-07-12Noblesville, IN16 shows sinceusual gap 8
  12. More2026-07-21Syracuse, NY1.7×10 shows sinceusual gap 6
  13. Bathtub Gin2026-07-24New York, NY1.6×8 shows sinceusual gap 5
  14. Slave to the Traffic Light2026-07-24New York, NY1.6×8 shows sinceusual gap 5

Slipping

Well past their usual gap rather than a little past it. These could turn up, and they could equally be on their way out of rotation — either way they are not what anybody is expecting tonight. The usual gap beside each one is measured over the last ten years of its performances, so for a song this far past it, read it as the schedule the song was on.

SongLast playedHow late
  1. Death Don’t Hurt Very Long2024-08-07Grand Rapids, MI18×99 shows sinceusual gap 5.5
  2. I Never Needed You Like This Before2024-08-11Bethel, NY13.7×96 shows sinceusual gap 7
  3. Soul Planet2025-07-12North Charleston, SC7.1×57 shows sinceusual gap 8
  4. Party Time2024-08-18Dover, DE7.1×92 shows sinceusual gap 13
  5. Poor Heart2024-12-28New York, NY84 shows sinceusual gap 12
  6. Your Pet Cat2024-08-16Dover, DE6.7×94 shows sinceusual gap 14
  7. The Howling2025-09-16Alpharetta, GA42 shows sinceusual gap 7
  8. Winterqueen2024-12-30New York, NY5.5×82 shows sinceusual gap 15
  9. Set Your Soul Free2026-04-24Las Vegas, NV25 shows sinceusual gap 5
  10. Twist2026-07-08Madison, WI4.8×19 shows sinceusual gap 4
  11. I Always Wanted It This Way2025-06-24Pittsburgh, PA4.5×65 shows sinceusual gap 14.5
  12. Sugar Shack2024-08-29Commerce City, CO4.3×91 shows sinceusual gap 21
  13. Lawn Boy2025-07-25Saratoga Springs, NY48 shows sinceusual gap 12
  14. My Sweet One2025-01-29Cancun, Quintana Roo80 shows sinceusual gap 20
  15. Petrichor2025-07-09Columbus, OH3.9×59 shows sinceusual gap 15
  16. Grind2024-12-31New York, NY3.5×81 shows sinceusual gap 23
  17. Nellie Kane2025-07-03Boulder, CO3.0×62 shows sinceusual gap 20.5
  18. Fuck Your Face2024-12-28New York, NY2.9×84 shows sinceusual gap 29
  19. Sleeping Monkey2025-04-19Seattle, WA2.5×75 shows sinceusual gap 29.5
  20. Strawberry Letter 232025-07-25Saratoga Springs, NY2.0×48 shows sinceusual gap 23.5
  21. Cars Trucks Buses2025-07-20Chicago, IL1.9×51 shows sinceusual gap 26.5
  22. Camel Walk2025-07-15Philadelphia, PA1.8×55 shows sinceusual gap 30

↑ Back to top

On the shelf

Gone more than 100 shows — long enough that the habit they are being measured against has probably stopped being true. Note this is not the same as saying their return would be a bustout: these songs all still have a recent record, and this site reserves that word for songs that do not.

SongLast playedHow late
  1. Rise/Come Together2022-07-29Raleigh, NC23.8×190 shows sinceusual gap 8
  2. We Are Come to Outlive Our Brains2023-08-31Commerce City, CO22.8×137 shows sinceusual gap 6
  3. Crazy Sometimes2023-10-11Dayton, OH10.8×129 shows sinceusual gap 12
  4. Wombat2022-08-10Toronto, Ontario10.1×182 shows sinceusual gap 18
  5. Miss You2024-07-31St. Louis, MO7.7×104 shows sinceusual gap 13.5
  6. Mr. Completely2024-07-31St. Louis, MO6.9×104 shows sinceusual gap 15
  7. Show of Life2023-08-31Commerce City, CO4.6×137 shows sinceusual gap 29.5
  8. Train Song2024-08-06Grand Rapids, MI3.6×100 shows sinceusual gap 28

↑ Back to top

Out of rotation

Gone long enough that a return would be a bustout, and with no recent record left to be late against — so there is no lateness here to rank, and none of it is due. There are more of these than in the three lists above put together, and they are not one population: 55 were in rotation and left it, 55 were played a few times across the band’s whole life and never became a habit, and 174 were played once or twice and never again.

All 284, grouped by the year each was last heard

↑ Back to top